This is a rather odd book, as it is one of the earliest written fiction works about the Doctor and is notable for being the first original novel based on the series (something that would not happen again until the show went off the air over 20 years later). Most of the problems that the book suffers are not the fault of the book itself, but rather the design of Doctor Who in 1966. While some of the problems are humorous, such as the Doctor being referred to as Dr. Who and the Tardis being referred to as Tardis (as if that was the ship's name), but others are much more confusing, such as the Doctor's inability to believe that machine's could be sentient. The Doctor's disdain for his companions (in this case, peasants from midieval Europe) is also rather disconcerting. These two flaws, along with the averageness of the stories themselves are the primary reason that I only give this release three of five stars. The villains of the first story are rather nice, and are very similar to the Daleks and Cybermen in that they evoke ideas of human superiority to machines through emotions and irrationability. The second story contained in this audiobook is "Ten Fathom Pirates," in which the Doctor (traveling alone this time (one of the only times we ever see the first Doctor alone)) comes across a group of underwater pirates and finds himself roped into their pillaging. It's a fun simple story, reminiscient somewhat of Big Finish's Short Trips range (though this came much earlier). Overall, though these stories are among the least interesting Doctor Who stories I've read, the chance they present us to see how the Doctor was portrayed in early expanded media is invaluable and makes the listen well worth it.
0 Comments
|
Archives
November 2023
Categories
All
|